October 2026 Clinical Supervision Topic: Self-Compassion after Complex Trauma

I am on the last few pages of When Bad Things Happen to Good People by Jewish rabbi Harold Kushner. It was handed to me by my dad who picked it up at a yard sale (which is very on-brand for him).

In it, Kushner describes his experience of learning that his young son had a rare condition that would dramatically shorten his life. His son died at just fourteen. He explores his own depths in trying to understand why such a horrible thing would happen to an innocent child.

To make sense of his own experience, Kushner explores the ancient story of Job. In this story, Job is a man doing everything the “right” way (according to the strictures of that time), yet tragedy upon tragedy happens. I won’t spoil the ending.

What I find very interesting about Kushner’s gentle, clear, non-dogmatic, open-ended exploration is that many of us (both client and clinician) are grappling with these questions quite constantly. Why is this bad thing happening to me? Did I cause it somehow? Is it my fault? Am I bad? How can I prevent bad things happening to me and those I love?

For many of us with complex trauma, painful things happened when we were very young. As children, we may have received the message, directly or indirectly, that these things happened because there was something wrong with us. That we were bad, annoying, too much, or somehow responsible for the harmful choices someone else made.

Those messages can stay long after childhood ends.

When life's inevitable difficulties arise, they can reactivate those old beliefs. Instead of experiencing something as simply difficult, disappointing, or painful, we may experience it as evidence that we've done something wrong, that we're the problem, or that we're fundamentally bad.

In this way, ordinary difficulties in adulthood can feel like confirmation of the painful messages absorbed as children.

For clients who struggle with this sense of I’m bad, it’s my fault, etc., we’re going to look at loosening and tending to this through the lens of self-compassion. (Please see several past years of self-compassion posts here.) Most clients I’ve worked with seem to respond positively to the idea of self-compassion only after they understand what it actually means and feels like. (Most of them seem to resist it at first, understandably).

There is good research to support choosing the intervention of self-compassion for sticky shame. In one study, shame-prone participants who practiced self-compassion while working with a shame-inducing experience experienced less intense shame in the moment. After repeated practice, they also showed a significant reduction in their overall tendency toward shame at a two-week follow-up, something that wasn’t seen in the control groups (Johnson & O’Brien, 2013). Another study found that mindfulness and self-compassion were both associated with lower levels of shame, with self-compassion accounting for the relationship between mindfulness and shame (Sedighimornani, Rimes, & Verplanken, 2019). All good news!

In other words, the point isn’t simply to tell ourselves nicer things. Research suggests that practicing a different way of being with ourselves when shame gets activated can reduce its intensity and, with repeated practice, may lessen our tendency to fall into shame.

You might be wondering: what about my clients who generally are causing some of their own problems? Shouldn’t they be studying cause and effect instead? Well, self-compassion actually supports the motivation that leads to self-improvement. Brené Brown has long distinguished shame from accountability: shame gets us stuck in I am bad, while accountability requires us to be able to look at what I did and make a different choice.

So for all of us (again, clients and clinicians alike) who have behaviors and habits we genuinely need to change, self-compassion isn’t necessarily letting ourselves off the hook. It may actually help us become more able to face what happened, take responsibility, and do something different because we know we are loved, supported and good, regardless.

Self-compassion is 3 simple components (based on Kristin Neff’s work):

a. Mindfulness: noticing something is painful. Being with it, especially on the bodily-sensation level. Words help here too: ouch, this really hurts, I don’t like this, I’m feeling _____.

b. Common humanity: recognizing that suffering and imperfection are part of being human, and that we aren’t alone in these experiences.

c. Self-kindness: using touch and words to soothe and be with the pain. For example, a hand over your heart and words of comfort or understanding, like I’m so sorry this is happening, this may not be my fault (and I will work through this!), I love you, I’m here for you.

A simple 3–5 minute practice that, with repetition, can make a meaningful difference.

Come ready to discuss, practice, and figure out how to apply this in your various settings.

Previous
Previous

November 2026 Clinical Supervision Topic: Inclusivity, Cultural Humility and Curiosity

Next
Next

September 2026 Clinical Supervision Topic: Asking for Feedback